Navigating the Human Terrain: Change Management in Route Optimisation

Route Optimisation delivers distinct benefits to any supply chain operation, including reduced fuel costs, improved customer service, and increased productivity. However, implementing Route Optimisation is challenging. Ensuring adoption, overcoming resistance, and realising the targeted benefits require a sophisticated and sensitive project management approach.

The Promise of Route Optimisation

In today’s challenging economic environment, many organisations are exploring ways to reduce the cost of their supply chain. One such method is through Route Optimisation solutions, which leverage advanced algorithms and current and historical data to determine the most efficient routes for vehicles in a fleet. This approach, which minimises travel time and distance for a maximum number of pickups and deliveries, can significantly reduce operating costs per stop and consignment.

‍

Beyond the Algorithm: The Real-World Hurdles of Implementation

While the benefits are clear, the process of implementing Route Optimisation systems often presents significant practical challenges:

• From a technical perspective, typical challenges include rigorous data collection and preparation (e.g. addresses, geo-codes, maps, vehicles, drivers), integration with existing systems (e.g., order management, inventory, CRM systems), installation of GPS and telematics devices in vehicles, and more. 
• From a process perspective, Route Optimisation invariably involves the radical redesign of daily workflows within the supply chain operation and its interaction with other business operations, such as customer support, billing, or payroll.
• Finally, there is a human perspective. Dispatchers, drivers, and management must be trained to use the new platform. At the same time, they will need to familiarise themselves with new processes and workflows and new ways of (data-driven) decision-making.
  
  

IT architects, process engineers, and other experts can address technical and process challenges. However, human and organisational difficulties are often the most complex and critical to successful implementation.

‍

The Human Factor: Route Optimisation Drives Drastic Change

Route Optimisation implementations go beyond just introducing new technology and processes. They involve profound shifts in roles and responsibilities. For instance, drivers who previously had autonomy in determining their route sequences may struggle following system-generated instructions. Dispatchers, once the critical decision-makers for last-minute adjustments, might find it challenging to defer to algorithmic recommendations.

Moreover, the impact extends to operations management. Where previously limited statistics, often based on manual measurements, were used to evaluate performance, Route Optimisation systems introduce a wealth of data and metrics. This shift means no inefficiency goes unnoticed, creating a more transparent but potentially more pressured work environment.

Employees, particularly those who have been with the company for a long time, find changes to familiar routines and responsibilities difficult and emotional. (Even when they rationally understand and support the change!) 

If you are implementing a Route Optimisation system, don’t consider it a quick technical upgrade. Instead, see it as a comprehensive organisational change and prepare to deal with resistance at all levels.

The Vital Role of Change Management

Change management is a structured approach to transitioning individuals, teams, and organisations from their current state to a desired future state. It is vital to address resistance to new processes, redefined roles, and shifts in decision-making.

In Route Optimisation implementations, change management helps to:

1. Communicate how the new system, processes, and redefined roles support overall business goals, motivating employees to accept the change.
2. Bridge skill gaps by providing targeted training and support, including interpreting and acting on the new abundance of data.
3. Guide frontline employees and management to transition to data-driven decision-making and performance evaluation.
4. Create forums for feedback and adjustment, allowing employees to contribute to optimising the new processes and metrics.
   
   

By focusing on the people aspect of the transformation, change management increases the likelihood of successful adoption.

‍

A Critical Success Factor: Leveraging Employee Expertise

The key to success in Route Optimisation implementations is involving employees in the process from the very beginning. This serves two purposes: 

Firstly, it taps into invaluable real-world knowledge and experience that project managers and system developers may lack. Long-time employees intimately know their customers, understand the intricacies of the city's layout, and deeply understand what works (and doesn't work) in practice, even if it seems counterintuitive in theory. Their input can be invaluable in designing a system that not only optimises routes but also aligns with the practical realities of the job.

Secondly, it gives employees a voice in shaping their future work environment. People naturally want to have a say in changes affecting their daily tasks! Involving them in the process ensures that the new system enhances rather than hinders employees’ ability to perform their jobs effectively.  It also fosters a sense of ownership and engagement among the staff, significantly reducing resistance to change.

Sustaining Long-Term Success

Naturally, the journey doesn't end once the system is implemented. To maintain and amplify the benefits over time, organisations must foster a culture of continuous improvement. This involves regularly reviewing performance data, collecting feedback, and refining processes. It should also include ongoing training, ensuring employees can fully leverage the system's capabilities. And, of course, celebrating successes along the way.

As technology advances, it is essential to stay updated on the latest developments in Route Optimisation (through this blog, for example). This ensures that your newly implemented solution remains cutting-edge and continues to deliver competitive advantages.

‍

Conclusion: For Competitive Advantage, Embrace Change

Successful Route Optimisation ultimately balances advanced technology and human insight. Companies that master this balance will not just optimise their routes; they'll position themselves at the forefront of their industry, ready to meet future challenges and opportunities head-on.

‍